Law and Rights
The Met. Police and The Guardian
At least for now, the Metropolitan Police has called off its application for The Guardian to disclose journalistic sources - see the Met. Police News Statement of 20th September. As discussed in the previous post (here), the application was to be based on the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s.9. In a further development, the Met. has been called to explain its actions to the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee - see The Guardian 21st September. The Guardian's revelations about phone-hacking are a good example of investigative journalism bringing iniquity to the attention of the public. The protection offered by law to journalistic sources is important - see Law and Lawyers post. However, there is also an important point of principle relating to the confidentiality of information in the possession of the Police. The law, rightly, also protects that information from unauthorised disclosure and prosecutions under the Official Secrets Acts are a possibility. At times, these principles come into collision. However, at least for now, the dogs of war remain in their kennels.
Dale Farm, Oak Lane, Billericay - a serious issue
The stand-off between Basildon Council and "travellers" ensconced at Dale Farm almost came to a head on Monday 19th September but, after a further High Court hearing, the bailiffs were stood down for the time being. What of the actual decisions in the courts? Three years ago, the matter was considered by Collins J in McCarthy and others v Basildon District Council [2008] EWHC 987 (Admin). The Equality and Human Rights Commission intervened in the case. Collins J, who was presented with 23 lever arch files of material, gave a very detailed history of the situation and held that enforcement could not proceed immediately. He concluded by saying:
This matter has attracted international attention - see Institute of Race relations "Gypsy and Traveller evictions: Dale Farm odyssey continues" - Frances Webber 30th November 2010. Whatever the British government's stance, there is a very serious problem to be addressed. Steps taken, by various governments, have not proved to be sufficient to address this growing problem. As the Court of Appeal pointed out:
Channel 4's Dispatches programme looked at the problem on Monday evening 19th September - "The Fight for Dale Farm
The film showed furious residents across Britain campaigning about the way gypsies pitch camp illegally in local parks, the damage that they cause to public and private property as well as the mess and destruction that they leave behind. Attention was drawn to criminality as well as, in some cases, a threat to public health by the use of wooded areas as toilets. Some local authority sites were also shown to have absymally poor facilities. The programme also questioned whether Government proposals to crack down on unauthorised development will change the situation for better or worse, and explored the ever growing issues that local councils face as and when, under present government policy, they are given more freedom to decide on just how many places should be allocated for travellers in their areas.
Again, the dogs of war were brought out but returned, temporarily at least, to their kennels. As and when the eviction is complete, the letter of the law will have been upheld but the problem will remain unsolved and will undoubtedly move on to some other site.
Addendum 26th September: Dale Farm residents win temporary reprieve - The Guardian
Cry "Havoc !" and let slip the dogs of war ... William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar Act 3 Scene 1.
- We're One Of The Top 21 Consumer Rights Web Sites In The World
The Best Consumer Rights Sites in the WorldIn the entire world, only two law firms have a web site or blog that has been named one of the Top 21 Consumer Rights Information Sites. We're one of them and proud of the years of hard work that got...
- Intelligence And Security ~ An Important Report
12 March 2015 - The Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament has today published its Report 'Privacy and Security: A modern and transparent legal framework'. This Report includes, for the first time in a single document, a comprehensive...
- New Squatting Law In Force 1st September
The Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 section 144 creates a new criminal offence relating to "squatting." The section came into force on 1st September 2012. For details of the legislation see the earlier post of 9th...
- Using Pace 1984 To Obtain Disclosure Of Journalistic Material
NOTE: It has been announced that the Met. Police has decided, for the time being, NOT to seek The Guardian's sources of information. See the Met. Police News Release. This decision was taken after consultation with the CPS and other...
- Family Law And Legal Aid .... Do Families Not Bleed?
The High Court has quashed the tendering process used by the Legal Services Commission to award legal aid contracts to family law firms - see Law Society and Law Society Gazette. See also the earlier post on Law and Lawyers. Unfortunately,...
Law and Rights
Cry "Havoc!" and let slip the dogs of war
At least for now, the Metropolitan Police has called off its application for The Guardian to disclose journalistic sources - see the Met. Police News Statement of 20th September. As discussed in the previous post (here), the application was to be based on the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s.9. In a further development, the Met. has been called to explain its actions to the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee - see The Guardian 21st September. The Guardian's revelations about phone-hacking are a good example of investigative journalism bringing iniquity to the attention of the public. The protection offered by law to journalistic sources is important - see Law and Lawyers post. However, there is also an important point of principle relating to the confidentiality of information in the possession of the Police. The law, rightly, also protects that information from unauthorised disclosure and prosecutions under the Official Secrets Acts are a possibility. At times, these principles come into collision. However, at least for now, the dogs of war remain in their kennels.
The stand-off between Basildon Council and "travellers" ensconced at Dale Farm almost came to a head on Monday 19th September but, after a further High Court hearing, the bailiffs were stood down for the time being. What of the actual decisions in the courts? Three years ago, the matter was considered by Collins J in McCarthy and others v Basildon District Council [2008] EWHC 987 (Admin). The Equality and Human Rights Commission intervened in the case. Collins J, who was presented with 23 lever arch files of material, gave a very detailed history of the situation and held that enforcement could not proceed immediately. He concluded by saying:
65. There can be no doubt that the claimants cannot remain where they are and that the time must come when they will have to leave, whether voluntarily or by means of forcible eviction. Despite the difficulties they face and the absence at present of sufficient sites to meet their needs, Travellers and Gypsies must appreciate that the law will not tolerate developments without planning permission being obtained, particularly on Green Belt land, and will be likely to uphold enforcement action where the individual circumstances of those affected have been properly considered against the harm to the environment and to relations with the community. Nevertheless, it is necessary for all relevant matters to be properly taken into account and it is impossible not to have some sympathy with the problems created for Gypsies and Travellers by the lack of sufficient sites to cater for their proper needs.
66. I have no doubt that a decision to enforce under s.178 is likely to be unassailable in respect of most and perhaps all of the claimants in due course. But there are concerns which I have already spelt out. It seems to me that the approach to need has been too restrictive and that, following in particular the EERA report (albeit not accepted by the Council), further consideration should be given to whether any sites can be found in the district and whether any families can be allowed to remain for the time being. In addition, I do not think the possible effects of the homelessness duty have been sufficiently dealt with in the advice given to the committee. Finally, I think that the approach has been that the sites should be cleared rather than a consideration of whether there are any individual families whose circumstances are such, whether because of serious ill-health or the needs of their children, that in their individual cases eviction would be disproportionate. I am not to be taken as saying that there necessarily are any such, but I think that possibility should have been drawn to the committee's attention.
67. I am conscious that this decision may mean no more than that a little more time is given to the claimants and the Council may feel that yet further delay is to be deprecated. Nonetheless, the decision, whichever way it goes, must be based on consideration of all that is relevant. But in the circumstances for the reasons I have given I am persuaded that the decisions of 13 December 2007 cannot stand.
This matter has attracted international attention - see Institute of Race relations "Gypsy and Traveller evictions: Dale Farm odyssey continues" - Frances Webber 30th November 2010. Whatever the British government's stance, there is a very serious problem to be addressed. Steps taken, by various governments, have not proved to be sufficient to address this growing problem. As the Court of Appeal pointed out:
Different approaches to the problem have been attempted over the years. The duty on local authorities to provide sites was abolished in 1994. The present duty is to make provision for sites in development plans and to perform duties under the Housing Act 1996 ("the 1996 Act"). The current guidance from the government is in Office of the Deputy Prime Minister ("ODPM") Circular 01/2006 entitled "Planning for Gypsy and Traveller Caravan Sites".
Channel 4's Dispatches programme looked at the problem on Monday evening 19th September - "The Fight for Dale Farm
The film showed furious residents across Britain campaigning about the way gypsies pitch camp illegally in local parks, the damage that they cause to public and private property as well as the mess and destruction that they leave behind. Attention was drawn to criminality as well as, in some cases, a threat to public health by the use of wooded areas as toilets. Some local authority sites were also shown to have absymally poor facilities. The programme also questioned whether Government proposals to crack down on unauthorised development will change the situation for better or worse, and explored the ever growing issues that local councils face as and when, under present government policy, they are given more freedom to decide on just how many places should be allocated for travellers in their areas.
Again, the dogs of war were brought out but returned, temporarily at least, to their kennels. As and when the eviction is complete, the letter of the law will have been upheld but the problem will remain unsolved and will undoubtedly move on to some other site.
Addendum 26th September: Dale Farm residents win temporary reprieve - The Guardian
Cry "Havoc !" and let slip the dogs of war ... William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar Act 3 Scene 1.
- We're One Of The Top 21 Consumer Rights Web Sites In The World
The Best Consumer Rights Sites in the WorldIn the entire world, only two law firms have a web site or blog that has been named one of the Top 21 Consumer Rights Information Sites. We're one of them and proud of the years of hard work that got...
- Intelligence And Security ~ An Important Report
12 March 2015 - The Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament has today published its Report 'Privacy and Security: A modern and transparent legal framework'. This Report includes, for the first time in a single document, a comprehensive...
- New Squatting Law In Force 1st September
The Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 section 144 creates a new criminal offence relating to "squatting." The section came into force on 1st September 2012. For details of the legislation see the earlier post of 9th...
- Using Pace 1984 To Obtain Disclosure Of Journalistic Material
NOTE: It has been announced that the Met. Police has decided, for the time being, NOT to seek The Guardian's sources of information. See the Met. Police News Release. This decision was taken after consultation with the CPS and other...
- Family Law And Legal Aid .... Do Families Not Bleed?
The High Court has quashed the tendering process used by the Legal Services Commission to award legal aid contracts to family law firms - see Law Society and Law Society Gazette. See also the earlier post on Law and Lawyers. Unfortunately,...