Law and Rights
Among the most difficult criminal cases to investigate and prosecute are those relating to allegations of historical child abuse. Following the emergence of allegations against the late Jimmy Savile, a number of other cases have appeared as a result of Police investigations such as the Metropolitan Police's Operation Yewtree .
In October 2012, Commander Peter Spindler of the Metropolitan Police said:
"We are dealing with alleged abuse on an unprecedented scale. The profile of this operation has empowered a staggering number of victims to come forward to report the sexual exploitation which occurred during their childhood."
The investigation of such cases is complex, the decision for Crown Prosecutors as to whether to prosecute is very difficult and the conduct of a trial presents formidable difficulties in ensuring that, many years after the alleged events, the defendant receives a fair trial.
It is not appropriate to comment about any specific cases which may be likely to go to trial. However, it is to be hoped that those involved in these cases have read the incredibly impressive study by Professor Penney Lewis - "Delayed Prosecution for Childhood Sexual Abuse." The book is available for purchase - here.
The book looks at the response of the criminal justice systems of common law jurisdictions to these challenging cases. Matters considered include: the reasons why complainants may delay reporting abuse for many years; the debate over whether long-delayed criminal prosecutions should be brought; the common law remedy of abuse of process which can ensure that unfair or oppressive prosecutions do not proceed.
In 2009 the National Police Improvement Agency (NPIA) published Guidance on Investigating Child Abuse and Safeguarding Children
See also - Crown Prosecution Service - Prosecuting cases of child abuse and Safeguarding Children - Guidance on Children as Victims and Witnesses. The CPS notes that, in relation to historical cases, the following issues may arise: loss or deliberate destruction of evidence; witnesses deceased or untraceable; previous indication that no prosecution would follow; delay in making a complaint; trawling; collusion; compensation; changes in legislation.
In 2002, the Home Affairs Committee published Conduct of investigations into past cases of child abuse in children's homes and the government's response (2003) is here.
It is right that the book is not closed on such cases but it must also be right that investigations are conducted meticulously, prosecutions are only brought after the most thorough consideration and that trials are conducted by judges and lawyers well versed in this aspect of the criminal law. Even the allegation can be damning for an individual and the consequences of conviction will be immensely serious.
Some cases from the Channel Islands are also of interest since, in 2009, a decision was taken not to prosecute certain of the cases.
- Linebacker Michael Boley Faces Abuse Claims In Custody Case
NFL linebacker Michael Boley's child custody case has gotten a whole lot more complicated, now that he's accused of abusing his 5-year-old son. The New York Giants player, formerly of the Atlanta Falcons, was first accused...
- Lord Greville Janner Will Now Be Prosecuted
The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has reversed her earlier decision not to prosecute Lord Greville Janner on 22 counts of sexual offences allegedly committed against children - see the announcement by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). ...
- Rotherham ~ Sexual Exploitation Of Children ~ The Reports
Updated 3rd September The last week of August saw an explosion of media comment regarding sexual exploitation* of children in the South Yorkshire town of Rotherham in the years 1997-2013 - see ITV Report finds shocking scale of abuse The Jay Report: The...
- A Look At The Michael Turner Case (aka Michael Le Vell - Aka Soap Star Name Kevin Webster)
At the Crown Court sitting in Manchester, the case of R v Michael Turner was heard by His Honour Judge Henshall and a jury. Turner, probably better known as the actor who plays the Coronation Street character Kevin Webster, was charged with sexual...
- Sir Cyril Smith ~ Corroboration Of Evidence
Revelations relating to the activities of the late Sir Cyril Smith have been in the media - BBC Sir Cyril Smith: Former MP sexually abused boys, police say 27th November 2012. Sir Cyril's family are deeply saddened by these allegations...
Law and Rights
Prosecution of Historical Child Abuse
In October 2012, Commander Peter Spindler of the Metropolitan Police said:
"We are dealing with alleged abuse on an unprecedented scale. The profile of this operation has empowered a staggering number of victims to come forward to report the sexual exploitation which occurred during their childhood."
The investigation of such cases is complex, the decision for Crown Prosecutors as to whether to prosecute is very difficult and the conduct of a trial presents formidable difficulties in ensuring that, many years after the alleged events, the defendant receives a fair trial.
It is not appropriate to comment about any specific cases which may be likely to go to trial. However, it is to be hoped that those involved in these cases have read the incredibly impressive study by Professor Penney Lewis - "Delayed Prosecution for Childhood Sexual Abuse." The book is available for purchase - here.
The book looks at the response of the criminal justice systems of common law jurisdictions to these challenging cases. Matters considered include: the reasons why complainants may delay reporting abuse for many years; the debate over whether long-delayed criminal prosecutions should be brought; the common law remedy of abuse of process which can ensure that unfair or oppressive prosecutions do not proceed.
| The book's focus then turns to the trial of delayed childhood sexual abuse allegations, considering the use which can be made by the prosecution and defence of evidence of complaint and delay in complaint, and the methods by which the jury can be informed of the reasons why complainants may delay. The role of warnings to the jury about the absence of corroboration and the forensic disadvantage or prejudice which the defendant may have suffered as a result of the complainant's delay in coming forward is scrutinised. Particular problems raised in cases involving recovered memories, and those involving multiple allegations are analysed. Finally, retrospective assessment of trial fairness and the safety of convictions is considered. |
In 2009 the National Police Improvement Agency (NPIA) published Guidance on Investigating Child Abuse and Safeguarding Children
See also - Crown Prosecution Service - Prosecuting cases of child abuse and Safeguarding Children - Guidance on Children as Victims and Witnesses. The CPS notes that, in relation to historical cases, the following issues may arise: loss or deliberate destruction of evidence; witnesses deceased or untraceable; previous indication that no prosecution would follow; delay in making a complaint; trawling; collusion; compensation; changes in legislation.
In 2002, the Home Affairs Committee published Conduct of investigations into past cases of child abuse in children's homes and the government's response (2003) is here.
It is right that the book is not closed on such cases but it must also be right that investigations are conducted meticulously, prosecutions are only brought after the most thorough consideration and that trials are conducted by judges and lawyers well versed in this aspect of the criminal law. Even the allegation can be damning for an individual and the consequences of conviction will be immensely serious.
Some cases from the Channel Islands are also of interest since, in 2009, a decision was taken not to prosecute certain of the cases.
- Linebacker Michael Boley Faces Abuse Claims In Custody Case
NFL linebacker Michael Boley's child custody case has gotten a whole lot more complicated, now that he's accused of abusing his 5-year-old son. The New York Giants player, formerly of the Atlanta Falcons, was first accused...
- Lord Greville Janner Will Now Be Prosecuted
The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has reversed her earlier decision not to prosecute Lord Greville Janner on 22 counts of sexual offences allegedly committed against children - see the announcement by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). ...
- Rotherham ~ Sexual Exploitation Of Children ~ The Reports
Updated 3rd September The last week of August saw an explosion of media comment regarding sexual exploitation* of children in the South Yorkshire town of Rotherham in the years 1997-2013 - see ITV Report finds shocking scale of abuse The Jay Report: The...
- A Look At The Michael Turner Case (aka Michael Le Vell - Aka Soap Star Name Kevin Webster)
At the Crown Court sitting in Manchester, the case of R v Michael Turner was heard by His Honour Judge Henshall and a jury. Turner, probably better known as the actor who plays the Coronation Street character Kevin Webster, was charged with sexual...
- Sir Cyril Smith ~ Corroboration Of Evidence
Revelations relating to the activities of the late Sir Cyril Smith have been in the media - BBC Sir Cyril Smith: Former MP sexually abused boys, police say 27th November 2012. Sir Cyril's family are deeply saddened by these allegations...