View from Strasbourg ~ Paul Mahoney
Law and Rights

View from Strasbourg ~ Paul Mahoney

At the European Court of Human Rights, each member State of the Council of Europe has a judge from that State.  Paul Mahoney is the judge from the UK.  In the Law Society Gazette he has set out some of his views - Law Society Gazette 11th November - The UK?s judge at the European Court of Human Rights explains how it ?insures? nations against ?backsliding into totalitarian government?

'The Strasbourg court is no longer like some satellite in outer space,? the UK?s judge at the European Court of Human Rights, Paul Mahoney, tells the Gazette. Its rulings have become ?almost the common law of Europe?, he says, as the 47 member states of the Council of Europe (CoE) integrate them into their national laws.

That is a bold statement
given the UK coalition government?s repeated threats to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights (the convention), which it is the court?s responsibility to enforce. The government is regularly incensed by judgments from Strasbourg, where the court is based, allowing ?hate preachers? to appeal their deportations (for example). Another ruling, saying that a blanket ban on prisoners voting was unlawful, even made our prime minister feel ?sick?, or so David Cameron complained.

Mahoney, who replaced Sir Nicolas Bratza in November 2012, has little patience with such ?little England views?. He says: ?The UK is strong enough to absorb the flea bites of judgments that go against us. Our staying within the system is good news for Europe, in particular for member states that, unlike the UK, do not have a history of democracy behind them. The UK is a role model for the democratic protection and promotion of human rights.?

and later

'What does he say to complaints that Strasbourg overrides the sovereignty of parliament? He replies: ?A parliamentary majority would seem to imply a respect for democracy, but that isn?t always the case. Adolf Hitler and, more recently, Morsi in Egypt, were both democratically elected. To ensure the protection of individuals and institutions, you need some sort of international guarantee outside the national system. That is what the CoE and the court do. They are a kind of insurance policy against backsliding into totalitarianism.?

Full article at Law Society Gazette 11th November

Mr Mahoney was elected by the Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly following the submission of three names by the British government - Strasbourg insider become UK's next human rights judge - Telegraph 28th June 2012

Section II of the European Convention on Human Rights deals with the court and its judges.

- European Union Accession To The European Convention On Human Rights
Article 6(2) of the Treaty on European Union states that the Union shall accede to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.  Art 6(3) of the Treaty states that fundamental rights, as guaranteed by the...

- Human Rights ~ Recent News
Updated 11th September The European Court of Human Rights - based at Strasbourg - has announced that from 1st November 2012 its President will be Dean Spielmann from Luxembourg.  He will replace the current President - Sir Nicolas Bratza. ...

- Outrage !! Unelected Euro Judges Trampling On Our Democracy !
Updated 24th May ... Media Outrage - Much of the popular British media has expressed outrage at the European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber decision in Scoppola v Italy - (discussed in the previous post). The Daily Mail sees the decision as "Contempt...

- Uk Seeks To Minimise The Influence Of Strasbourg
Post updated 1st March A leaked document has revealed the hand which the UK government is playing in the run up to the High Level Conference on the Future of the European Court of Human Rights due to be held in Brighton in April 2012. The document may...

- Sir Nicolas Bratza: The European Court Of Human Rights
Updated with links to some other blogs To say the least, Sir Nicolas Bratza is a very eminent lawyer - see his profile on the Bar Council website.  His CV is also on the European Court of Human Rights website.  Sir Nicolas was in private practice...

Law and Rights