Law and Rights
The House of Commons Justice Committee has expressed grave misgivings about whether the Criminal Courts Charge is compatible with the principles of justice - READ THE REPORT. The levels of the charge are criticised as grossly disproportionate to the means of many of the offenders to which the charge is applicable as well as to the gravity of many of the offences for which it is imposed. The charge is also thought to be creating perverse incentives affecting defendant and sentencer behaviour.
The committee would not mourn early abolition of the charge and calls for legislation to either remove it or, if the government is not so minded, to reduce the levels of the charge. If it is not either abolished or reduced then the committee calls for legislation to permit discretion for sentencers (a) as to whether to impose the charge and (b) if it is imposed, the level of the charge.
The message is clear enough. Abolish this unjust charge.
Previous post explaining the charge
- Nissan's New Leaf Jumps To Head Of The Line
Nissan appears to have a winner with its new Leaf electric vehicle, coming to a Nissan dealer near you in the near future. Some 14,000 consumers have lined up and plunked down a refundable $99 to get on the Leaf waiting list. But what are they really...
- A Case Of Begging ~ Criminal Court Charge ~ Speech By Lady Hale
Steffan Rowland Thomas - aged 19 - was seen by a PCSO sitting in the doorway of an empty shop in Swansea. He was asking passers-by for money. The matter came before Swansea Magistrates' Court where Thomas entered a guilty plea. The...
- It's In The Bag ....!
Five pence per plastic carrier bag! I am all for protecting the environment as far as we can and so I assume that the carrier bag idea is a sensible innovation - The Telegraph 4th October - Carrier Bag 5p charge: Everything you need to know. ...
- Car Parking ~ £85 Overstay Charge Upheld
Parking Eye Ltd v Barry Beavis [2015] EWCA Civ 402 is an interesting case heard by the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) in April 2015. In the County Court (before His Honour Judge Moloney QC), Mr Beavis had lost his claim to recover a charge of...
- Criminal Court Charges - Again !
The following tweet requires little by way of explanation. The relevant legislation may be seen via my earlier blogpost - Criminal Court Charges. The impact of this on the rate of guilty-pleas remains to be seen but it seems likely that some will...
Law and Rights
Criminal Courts Charge - Justice Committee Report
The committee would not mourn early abolition of the charge and calls for legislation to either remove it or, if the government is not so minded, to reduce the levels of the charge. If it is not either abolished or reduced then the committee calls for legislation to permit discretion for sentencers (a) as to whether to impose the charge and (b) if it is imposed, the level of the charge.
The message is clear enough. Abolish this unjust charge.
Previous post explaining the charge
- Nissan's New Leaf Jumps To Head Of The Line
Nissan appears to have a winner with its new Leaf electric vehicle, coming to a Nissan dealer near you in the near future. Some 14,000 consumers have lined up and plunked down a refundable $99 to get on the Leaf waiting list. But what are they really...
- A Case Of Begging ~ Criminal Court Charge ~ Speech By Lady Hale
Steffan Rowland Thomas - aged 19 - was seen by a PCSO sitting in the doorway of an empty shop in Swansea. He was asking passers-by for money. The matter came before Swansea Magistrates' Court where Thomas entered a guilty plea. The...
- It's In The Bag ....!
Five pence per plastic carrier bag! I am all for protecting the environment as far as we can and so I assume that the carrier bag idea is a sensible innovation - The Telegraph 4th October - Carrier Bag 5p charge: Everything you need to know. ...
- Car Parking ~ £85 Overstay Charge Upheld
Parking Eye Ltd v Barry Beavis [2015] EWCA Civ 402 is an interesting case heard by the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) in April 2015. In the County Court (before His Honour Judge Moloney QC), Mr Beavis had lost his claim to recover a charge of...
- Criminal Court Charges - Again !
The following tweet requires little by way of explanation. The relevant legislation may be seen via my earlier blogpost - Criminal Court Charges. The impact of this on the rate of guilty-pleas remains to be seen but it seems likely that some will...