Law and Rights
The Guardian 27th August carried an article "Justice buses are not the answer to court closures". Ideas such as "courts" sitting in shopping centres and on converted buses have been popping up recently. For many practical reasons, this is most unlikely to happen. As a cost-saving exercise, the number of magistrates' courts in England and Wales will be reduced over the next 18 months to 2 years. The consequence will be that summary justice will be less locally administered for many people. Victims and witnesses will have to travel further and go to unfamiliar places to give their evidence. Possibly, even the Police may end up being less keen to prosecute cases if officers have to be away from their base attending a distant court.
The article's author (Jon Robins) wrote - "There is also a question over the volunteer army of magistrates which has played such a fundamental part in the justice system, many of whom are about to be made homeless. Ken Clarke's glib comments that the locality of the courts depended on "how far it was reasonable for a man to ride a horse" suggest that he will not be overly troubled by abstract arguments in favour of local justice.
It is ironic that as justices of the peace contemplate their 650th anniversary next year, they face the greatest threat to their existence in living memory. They will have to make the case that they have a role outside their soon-to-be closed courthouses, hence the talk from the Magistrates Association of justice buses and supermarket courts. It is going to be a challenge."
Personally, I do not see that either the Magistrates Association nor individual magistrates need to make any case for a "role outside their soon-to-be-closed courthouses". Why should they? The responsibility for the demise of local justice - (by which I mean locally administered justice) - ought to rest with those Ministers who are advocating the cuts. Is this a case of government knowing the price of everything and the value of nothing? I would be interested in views on the vital topics of court closures and local justice. These changes are likely to affect all of us eventually.
See Ministry of Justice for more details of specific proposals to close local courts.
See also CharonQC - "Law Review: an even more daft idea from a magistrate"
- Reforming The Role Of Magistrates
This morning I draw attention to an article in Modern Law Review (November 2014) - Reforming the role of Magistrates: Implications for summary justice in England and Wales The article may be obtained (£) from the Wiley Online Library. The Library...
- A Jewel Beyond Price ... The Magistracy Of England And Wales
Kidderminster Magistrates Court2011 marks the 650th Anniversary of the Justices of the Peace Act 1361. The Office of Justice of the Peace may have originated earlier than 1361 since, as early as 1195, a proclamation was made requiring the...
- Courts Facing Closure: Views Of Lord Justice Goldring --- And Other Matters
On 6th September we asked ?Is ?Justice? in safe hands?? That post looked (amongst other things) at the cuts to the Magistrates? Courts: ?The previous Labour government started the hatchet job on magistrates' courts and the axe has been...
- The Axe To Be Taken To Some 157 Courts
The Ministry of Justice, recognising the present financial climate, is keen to axe to some 157 Court locations. The majority are Magistrates' Courts but over 50 are County Courts. On 23rd June a series of consultation papers were published...
- Local Justice Is Getting Less Local
In recent times, the Magistrates' Courts have been equated with the term "local justice", a phrase which implies courts being reasonably near to people (who may have to attend as witnesses etc) and justice administered by people (magistrates) who...
Law and Rights
Justice Buses are not the answer to court closures ....
The article's author (Jon Robins) wrote - "There is also a question over the volunteer army of magistrates which has played such a fundamental part in the justice system, many of whom are about to be made homeless. Ken Clarke's glib comments that the locality of the courts depended on "how far it was reasonable for a man to ride a horse" suggest that he will not be overly troubled by abstract arguments in favour of local justice.
It is ironic that as justices of the peace contemplate their 650th anniversary next year, they face the greatest threat to their existence in living memory. They will have to make the case that they have a role outside their soon-to-be closed courthouses, hence the talk from the Magistrates Association of justice buses and supermarket courts. It is going to be a challenge."
Personally, I do not see that either the Magistrates Association nor individual magistrates need to make any case for a "role outside their soon-to-be-closed courthouses". Why should they? The responsibility for the demise of local justice - (by which I mean locally administered justice) - ought to rest with those Ministers who are advocating the cuts. Is this a case of government knowing the price of everything and the value of nothing? I would be interested in views on the vital topics of court closures and local justice. These changes are likely to affect all of us eventually.
See Ministry of Justice for more details of specific proposals to close local courts.
See also CharonQC - "Law Review: an even more daft idea from a magistrate"
- Reforming The Role Of Magistrates
This morning I draw attention to an article in Modern Law Review (November 2014) - Reforming the role of Magistrates: Implications for summary justice in England and Wales The article may be obtained (£) from the Wiley Online Library. The Library...
- A Jewel Beyond Price ... The Magistracy Of England And Wales
Kidderminster Magistrates Court2011 marks the 650th Anniversary of the Justices of the Peace Act 1361. The Office of Justice of the Peace may have originated earlier than 1361 since, as early as 1195, a proclamation was made requiring the...
- Courts Facing Closure: Views Of Lord Justice Goldring --- And Other Matters
On 6th September we asked ?Is ?Justice? in safe hands?? That post looked (amongst other things) at the cuts to the Magistrates? Courts: ?The previous Labour government started the hatchet job on magistrates' courts and the axe has been...
- The Axe To Be Taken To Some 157 Courts
The Ministry of Justice, recognising the present financial climate, is keen to axe to some 157 Court locations. The majority are Magistrates' Courts but over 50 are County Courts. On 23rd June a series of consultation papers were published...
- Local Justice Is Getting Less Local
In recent times, the Magistrates' Courts have been equated with the term "local justice", a phrase which implies courts being reasonably near to people (who may have to attend as witnesses etc) and justice administered by people (magistrates) who...