Law and Rights
Save Justice - The government is changing legal aid! It will affect you! This explains why.
The campaign against the government's proposals for Reforming legal aid continues so please consider signing the e-petition on Legal Aid. This seeks to persuade the House of Commons that a debate is necessary about proposals which will put numerous firms of high street solicitors out of business, effectively remove your right to choose your solicitor, hand public money to a chosen few private suppliers of legal aid work, and devastate the independent criminal bar. Even if you get legal aid and are acquitted, you may still have to pay a considerable contribution to your own defence. This could lead to many DIY defendants: people who feel forced to defend themselves rather than expose their savings and home to a legal aid contribution. Surely, the Secretary of State should not be simply allowed to sign this into law. Parliament must do its job and hold him to account.
The consequences for those charged
are likely to be devastating and you never know when it might be you (e.g. a moment's lack of concentration when driving which has serious consequences) or a member of your family such as a young person out with friends who gets caught up in some event. Please note carefully: the government will always ensure that it is represented by the best lawyers. No cuts are proposed to the prosecution side.
Excellent articles have appeared - The government's purge of legal aid crosses the border into authoritarianism and tyranny - Conservative Student 20th May - and Natural justice faces a savage loss of innocence - Nick Cohen - 15th June 2013. Please read them and call upon your MP to oppose the Grayling plans.
The media has been riddled with seriously misleading articles about the earnings of legal aid lawyers. An attempt to rectify this is at Mail on Sunday corrects daily's legal aid sums. It is little use denying the fact that some lawyers obtain high fees from legal aid - a matter I covered in my post the other day - Yuppy, beady-eyed crowds; Fat Cats and Moggies! Wednesday thoughts. There are complex and lengthy cases where the most expert of lawyers are needed but, even in such Very High Cost Cases (VHCCs), the Bar Council has proposed an alternative funding scheme (Graduated Fee Scheme - or GFS) which would save the government money. The fact remains that, for most lawyers practising in criminal legal aid, income is very low to moderate. This was made very clear by one lawyer who simply cannot afford to continue - This is what is happening to honest hard working legal aid lawyers, and why.
During a radio programme, Lord McNally (Minister of State for Justice) was interviewed by Joshua Rozenberg. McNally sought to defend the government's position but, in doing so, acted in a particularly petulant manner. He came across as irritated that anyone should have the temerity to question the Ministry's proposals. Of course, he has his position in the Lords for life and need never face the electorate to answer for anything. A MUST read is the evisceration of Lord McNally by Guy Gozem QC - Lord McNally's balloons.
On 11th June, at the Justice Committee hearing leading representatives of the legal profession explained the professional opposition to the Grayling proposals - especially those for Price Competitive Tendering (PCT). It was made clear that the professions are willing to engage with government about saving money but they will not go along with a Blitzkrieg on access to justice and fair trial rights for the population.
Please stand up and be counted: sign the e-petition on Legal Aid.
- The Justice Committee ~ Hearing Of 3rd July 2013 ~ Legal Aid
Update - 3rd July: The session is over - Watch it Here. Update 4th July: Solicitors Journal Fresh consultation to be launched in September after 'detailed talks' with Law Society Chris Grayling, the justice secretary, put...
- Legal Aid - A Possible Shift In The Government's Position - Law Society's Alternative Proposals
Mr Chris Grayling MPUpdated 4th July - see addendum: Beset on all sides by criticism of plans to reform criminal legal aid and in advance of his appearance before the Justice Committee on 3rd July, the Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor...
- No To Pct - Backbench Legal Aid Debate Coming Up 27th June
I do not deny that government needs to save money though I seriously question some of its priorities (e.g. Trident replacement, ring-fencing of the huge overseas aid budget etc). The government's latest legal aid proposals are to be debated...
- Act Now To Try To Stop 'justice' Being Only For The Rich And Powerful
*** Please sign the e-petition on Legal Aid - the aim is to try to persuade Parliament to debate the Ministry of Justice plans to slash legal aid. Why should any Minister be allowed to seriously alter the rights of the British citizen just by stroke...
- The Real 'scumbag Criminal' Is Still Free ~ A Matter At Democracy's Heart
Update 28th May - this post was kindly reproduced by Legal Business - here Updated 21st May with some further links 'Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere' - Martin Luther King - Letter from a Birmingham Jail - 16th April 1963...
Law and Rights
Legal Aid: that was the week that was.
The campaign against the government's proposals for Reforming legal aid continues so please consider signing the e-petition on Legal Aid. This seeks to persuade the House of Commons that a debate is necessary about proposals which will put numerous firms of high street solicitors out of business, effectively remove your right to choose your solicitor, hand public money to a chosen few private suppliers of legal aid work, and devastate the independent criminal bar. Even if you get legal aid and are acquitted, you may still have to pay a considerable contribution to your own defence. This could lead to many DIY defendants: people who feel forced to defend themselves rather than expose their savings and home to a legal aid contribution. Surely, the Secretary of State should not be simply allowed to sign this into law. Parliament must do its job and hold him to account.
The consequences for those charged
are likely to be devastating and you never know when it might be you (e.g. a moment's lack of concentration when driving which has serious consequences) or a member of your family such as a young person out with friends who gets caught up in some event. Please note carefully: the government will always ensure that it is represented by the best lawyers. No cuts are proposed to the prosecution side.
Excellent articles have appeared - The government's purge of legal aid crosses the border into authoritarianism and tyranny - Conservative Student 20th May - and Natural justice faces a savage loss of innocence - Nick Cohen - 15th June 2013. Please read them and call upon your MP to oppose the Grayling plans.
The media has been riddled with seriously misleading articles about the earnings of legal aid lawyers. An attempt to rectify this is at Mail on Sunday corrects daily's legal aid sums. It is little use denying the fact that some lawyers obtain high fees from legal aid - a matter I covered in my post the other day - Yuppy, beady-eyed crowds; Fat Cats and Moggies! Wednesday thoughts. There are complex and lengthy cases where the most expert of lawyers are needed but, even in such Very High Cost Cases (VHCCs), the Bar Council has proposed an alternative funding scheme (Graduated Fee Scheme - or GFS) which would save the government money. The fact remains that, for most lawyers practising in criminal legal aid, income is very low to moderate. This was made very clear by one lawyer who simply cannot afford to continue - This is what is happening to honest hard working legal aid lawyers, and why.
During a radio programme, Lord McNally (Minister of State for Justice) was interviewed by Joshua Rozenberg. McNally sought to defend the government's position but, in doing so, acted in a particularly petulant manner. He came across as irritated that anyone should have the temerity to question the Ministry's proposals. Of course, he has his position in the Lords for life and need never face the electorate to answer for anything. A MUST read is the evisceration of Lord McNally by Guy Gozem QC - Lord McNally's balloons.
On 11th June, at the Justice Committee hearing leading representatives of the legal profession explained the professional opposition to the Grayling proposals - especially those for Price Competitive Tendering (PCT). It was made clear that the professions are willing to engage with government about saving money but they will not go along with a Blitzkrieg on access to justice and fair trial rights for the population.
Please stand up and be counted: sign the e-petition on Legal Aid.
Even tho legal aid change will hurt millions of people, at least it'll liberate £200m to give to banks. They only got £90,000,000,000 before
? Gary Slapper (@garyslapper) June 16, 2013
- The Justice Committee ~ Hearing Of 3rd July 2013 ~ Legal Aid
Update - 3rd July: The session is over - Watch it Here. Update 4th July: Solicitors Journal Fresh consultation to be launched in September after 'detailed talks' with Law Society Chris Grayling, the justice secretary, put...
- Legal Aid - A Possible Shift In The Government's Position - Law Society's Alternative Proposals
Mr Chris Grayling MPUpdated 4th July - see addendum: Beset on all sides by criticism of plans to reform criminal legal aid and in advance of his appearance before the Justice Committee on 3rd July, the Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor...
- No To Pct - Backbench Legal Aid Debate Coming Up 27th June
I do not deny that government needs to save money though I seriously question some of its priorities (e.g. Trident replacement, ring-fencing of the huge overseas aid budget etc). The government's latest legal aid proposals are to be debated...
- Act Now To Try To Stop 'justice' Being Only For The Rich And Powerful
*** Please sign the e-petition on Legal Aid - the aim is to try to persuade Parliament to debate the Ministry of Justice plans to slash legal aid. Why should any Minister be allowed to seriously alter the rights of the British citizen just by stroke...
- The Real 'scumbag Criminal' Is Still Free ~ A Matter At Democracy's Heart
Update 28th May - this post was kindly reproduced by Legal Business - here Updated 21st May with some further links 'Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere' - Martin Luther King - Letter from a Birmingham Jail - 16th April 1963...