Law and Rights
Justice Minister Mr Damian Green is seeking to improve the performance of the Magistrates Courts - Ministry of Justice - Damian Green: unacceptable delays in Magistrates Courts. He is right to do so but, let's remember, there have been several quite recent 'initiatives' aimed at the same thing: Criminal Justice: Simple, Speedy, Summary (CJSSS); Making it Count (in Youth Courts); Stop delaying Justice and also considerable emphasis on Case Management.
The Defence Brief blog recently drew attention to some of the problems - Courts are a Farce. There is no reason to suppose that the inefficiencies referred to are all that unusual and the Justice Minister would do well to read it.
Anyone inclined to think that inefficiency is a recent innovation
should read a post on The Magistrates' Blog in May 2007 which drew attention to problems with the Crown Prosecution Service - CJSSS+CPS=SFA.
Since the Courts Act 2003, the Magistrates Courts have undergone profound changes in the way they are administered. These may not have been entirely for the better. Of course, as is so often the case, change has been piled on change with the system having to embrace court closures on a huge scale together with loss of experienced staff - a process which has probably not ended.
A further point well worth noting is that most of the problems lie with the professionals and NOT with the volunteer Justices of the Peace - those judicial beasts of burden who continue to serve so well. Attend any Magistrates' Court and the bench is always there to start hearings at the appointed time but so rarely is the professional side entirely ready.
Criminal offences are dealt with either by out of court methods (e.g. cautions, penalty notices etc) or by the Magistrates Courts or, for serious cases, by the Crown Court. The reality is that the vast majority of offences fall to be disposed of by the first two methods. The Magistrates Courts are therefore of critical importance to criminal justice and they merit better attention than they appear to be receiving.
- Reforming The Role Of Magistrates
This morning I draw attention to an article in Modern Law Review (November 2014) - Reforming the role of Magistrates: Implications for summary justice in England and Wales The article may be obtained (£) from the Wiley Online Library. The Library...
- Stop Delaying Justice !
Salford Magistrates Court - closes end of 2011"Stop Delaying Justice" is a new initiative in the Magistrates' Courts and will take effect from 1st January 2012. The excellent materials available from Crimeline explain this more and comment that...
- Magistrates' Courts
Magistrates' Courts deal with the bulk of criminal cases brought to court in England and Wales. The judiciary in a magistrates' court comprises the Justices of the Peace (JPs or, as they are often referred to these days, "lay magistrates")...
- Reports Coming Thick And Fast: Victims Commissioner: Police Inspectorate
In March 2010, as the general election approached, Louise Casey was appointed Commissioner for Victims and Witnesses by Jack Straw (read). She has produced a short 4 page report which, to be fair, levels valid criticisms at the criminal justice...
- The Lord Chief Justice Expresses Concerns .....
The Lord Chief Justice has published his "Review of the Adminstration of Justice in the Courts." The Review covers the legal year 1st October 2008 to 30th September 2009. 1. Concern is raised (para. 2.12) about the use of out-of-court methods of...
Law and Rights
Magistrates Courts ~ Unacceptable delays
The Defence Brief blog recently drew attention to some of the problems - Courts are a Farce. There is no reason to suppose that the inefficiencies referred to are all that unusual and the Justice Minister would do well to read it.
Anyone inclined to think that inefficiency is a recent innovation
should read a post on The Magistrates' Blog in May 2007 which drew attention to problems with the Crown Prosecution Service - CJSSS+CPS=SFA.
Since the Courts Act 2003, the Magistrates Courts have undergone profound changes in the way they are administered. These may not have been entirely for the better. Of course, as is so often the case, change has been piled on change with the system having to embrace court closures on a huge scale together with loss of experienced staff - a process which has probably not ended.
A further point well worth noting is that most of the problems lie with the professionals and NOT with the volunteer Justices of the Peace - those judicial beasts of burden who continue to serve so well. Attend any Magistrates' Court and the bench is always there to start hearings at the appointed time but so rarely is the professional side entirely ready.
Criminal offences are dealt with either by out of court methods (e.g. cautions, penalty notices etc) or by the Magistrates Courts or, for serious cases, by the Crown Court. The reality is that the vast majority of offences fall to be disposed of by the first two methods. The Magistrates Courts are therefore of critical importance to criminal justice and they merit better attention than they appear to be receiving.
- Reforming The Role Of Magistrates
This morning I draw attention to an article in Modern Law Review (November 2014) - Reforming the role of Magistrates: Implications for summary justice in England and Wales The article may be obtained (£) from the Wiley Online Library. The Library...
- Stop Delaying Justice !
Salford Magistrates Court - closes end of 2011"Stop Delaying Justice" is a new initiative in the Magistrates' Courts and will take effect from 1st January 2012. The excellent materials available from Crimeline explain this more and comment that...
- Magistrates' Courts
Magistrates' Courts deal with the bulk of criminal cases brought to court in England and Wales. The judiciary in a magistrates' court comprises the Justices of the Peace (JPs or, as they are often referred to these days, "lay magistrates")...
- Reports Coming Thick And Fast: Victims Commissioner: Police Inspectorate
In March 2010, as the general election approached, Louise Casey was appointed Commissioner for Victims and Witnesses by Jack Straw (read). She has produced a short 4 page report which, to be fair, levels valid criticisms at the criminal justice...
- The Lord Chief Justice Expresses Concerns .....
The Lord Chief Justice has published his "Review of the Adminstration of Justice in the Courts." The Review covers the legal year 1st October 2008 to 30th September 2009. 1. Concern is raised (para. 2.12) about the use of out-of-court methods of...