Law and Rights
The manslaughter of 6 children as a result of a deliberately set fire must rank high in the catalogue of heinous crimes. The sentencing remarks of Mrs Justice Thirlwall in the case of Philpott, Philpott and Mosley are available. The children ranged in age from 5 to 13 and they died as a direct result of a fire set by the three defendants. Thirlwall J noted that, of the 3 defendants, Michael Philpott was the 'driving force behind this shockingly dangerous enterprise.'
Michael Philpott was sentenced to life imprisonment and must serve a minimum of 15 years before parole may be considered. There is no guarantee that he will be released after the 15 years. Life sentences are explained here and also see Ministry of Justice Life sentenced prisoners
Mairead Philpott (mother of the children) and Paul Mosley (family friend) were each sentenced to 17 years imprisonment and must serve half before release on licence.
Forget the political side show about the benefits Philpott received. Thirlwall J got to the heart of his true character and the appalling deed he committed. In the judge's words, Philpott is a 'disturbingly dangerous man' with 'no moral compass.'
The judge
referred to the only proper course being to sentence Michael Philpott to life imprisonment. The statutory provisions relating to sentence are very convoluted. Here, the Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act 2000 s82A would have applied. Early release provisions - in the Crime (Sentences Act 1997) - are normally applied. However, there is section 82A(4) and this enables the sentencing court to order that early release provisions shall not apply. Clearly, the court would reserve this power for the most serious of offences. Unfortunately, the judge's sentencing remarks do not indicate whether this power was considered. Michael Philpott's case is one where it might be thought that the the use of that power would have been merited.
Halsbury's Law Exchange - Philpott - why wasn't it murder and when will he be free? Barrister, Felicity Gerrity
Benefits in Britain: Separating the facts from the fiction - The Guardian 6th April 2013
- Sentencing In R V Adebolajo And Adebowale
The men found guilty of the murder, on the afternoon of 22nd May 2013 at Woolwich, of Fusilier Lee Rigby have now been sentenced. A whole life term was imposed by Mr Justice Sweeney on Michael Adebolajo. A 45 year minimum term was imposed...
- R V Abdulrahman ~ Grievous Bodily Harm To Baby ~ Post Partum Psychosis ~ Sentencing
In the Crown Court at Birmingham, Mrs Justice Thirlwall has imposed a sentence of 30 months imprisonment on Jaymin Abdulrahman who was convicted of causing grievous bodily harm to her then six day old baby in September 2012. The judge's concise...
- R V Benjamin Curtis ~ Sentencing ~ Manslaughter (by Shaking) Of Baby
Benjamin Curtis has been sentenced to serve 2 years imprisonment for the manslaughter of Ocean Elliott. The brief sentencing remarks of Nicol J are available via the Judiciary website - (HERE). The judge described Curtis as having learning...
- Murder: Crown Court At Preston ~ R V Cregan, Livesey, Gorman, Wilkinson, Ward And Ali
At the Crown Court (Preston) after a 77 day trial before Holroyde J and a jury, a sentence of imprisonment for life with a whole life term has been imposed on Dale Cregan. He is guilty of four murders (including two Police Officers in September...
- The Legal Aid, Sentencing And Punishment Of Offenders Bill - Further Amendments And A Bit Of Henry Viii
The passage of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill (LASPO) through the Commons is almost complete with the report stage set for 31st October. It is therefore interesting that on 26th October, the Ministry of Justice announced ...
Law and Rights
R v Philpott, Philpott and Mosley ~ Sentencing remarks of Mrs Justice Thirlwall
Michael Philpott was sentenced to life imprisonment and must serve a minimum of 15 years before parole may be considered. There is no guarantee that he will be released after the 15 years. Life sentences are explained here and also see Ministry of Justice Life sentenced prisoners
Mairead Philpott (mother of the children) and Paul Mosley (family friend) were each sentenced to 17 years imprisonment and must serve half before release on licence.
Forget the political side show about the benefits Philpott received. Thirlwall J got to the heart of his true character and the appalling deed he committed. In the judge's words, Philpott is a 'disturbingly dangerous man' with 'no moral compass.'
The judge
referred to the only proper course being to sentence Michael Philpott to life imprisonment. The statutory provisions relating to sentence are very convoluted. Here, the Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act 2000 s82A would have applied. Early release provisions - in the Crime (Sentences Act 1997) - are normally applied. However, there is section 82A(4) and this enables the sentencing court to order that early release provisions shall not apply. Clearly, the court would reserve this power for the most serious of offences. Unfortunately, the judge's sentencing remarks do not indicate whether this power was considered. Michael Philpott's case is one where it might be thought that the the use of that power would have been merited.
Halsbury's Law Exchange - Philpott - why wasn't it murder and when will he be free? Barrister, Felicity Gerrity
Benefits in Britain: Separating the facts from the fiction - The Guardian 6th April 2013
- Sentencing In R V Adebolajo And Adebowale
The men found guilty of the murder, on the afternoon of 22nd May 2013 at Woolwich, of Fusilier Lee Rigby have now been sentenced. A whole life term was imposed by Mr Justice Sweeney on Michael Adebolajo. A 45 year minimum term was imposed...
- R V Abdulrahman ~ Grievous Bodily Harm To Baby ~ Post Partum Psychosis ~ Sentencing
In the Crown Court at Birmingham, Mrs Justice Thirlwall has imposed a sentence of 30 months imprisonment on Jaymin Abdulrahman who was convicted of causing grievous bodily harm to her then six day old baby in September 2012. The judge's concise...
- R V Benjamin Curtis ~ Sentencing ~ Manslaughter (by Shaking) Of Baby
Benjamin Curtis has been sentenced to serve 2 years imprisonment for the manslaughter of Ocean Elliott. The brief sentencing remarks of Nicol J are available via the Judiciary website - (HERE). The judge described Curtis as having learning...
- Murder: Crown Court At Preston ~ R V Cregan, Livesey, Gorman, Wilkinson, Ward And Ali
At the Crown Court (Preston) after a 77 day trial before Holroyde J and a jury, a sentence of imprisonment for life with a whole life term has been imposed on Dale Cregan. He is guilty of four murders (including two Police Officers in September...
- The Legal Aid, Sentencing And Punishment Of Offenders Bill - Further Amendments And A Bit Of Henry Viii
The passage of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill (LASPO) through the Commons is almost complete with the report stage set for 31st October. It is therefore interesting that on 26th October, the Ministry of Justice announced ...