Law and Rights
3rd December - Updated with further links
Whether or not there is a collective noun for "speeches" - (perhaps a "conference" of speeches?) - there have been many in recent days.
Lord Judge - former Lord Chief Justice - Bar Council Annual Law Reform Lecture 21st November - The evidence of child victims: the next stage
Speeches by Supreme Court Justices:
Lord Sumption - 27th Sultan Azlan Shah Lecture, Kuala Lumpur - The Limits of Law
Lord Justice Laws - Hamlyn Lectures 2013 - Lecture 3 Common Law and Europe The first two Hamlyn lectures are entitled - 1. Common Law and State Powre - 2. Common Law and Extremism.
In an article, Lord Neuberger (President of the Supreme Court) expressed views about short term prison sentences sentencing - Daily Mail 26th November - "One of the country?s most senior judges provoked fury last night when he criticised short jail sentences for interfering with the home lives of criminals. Lord Neuberger, president of the Supreme Court, said he rejected the idea that a couple of months behind bars ? and what he called ?the clang of the prison gates? ? could help bring criminals to their senses. Instead, he warned such sentences ?can be disruptive? for the prisoner?s job and home life. The judge made his comments after visiting Holloway women?s prison in North London."
Sir Rabinder Singh - The Unity of Law - or the dangers of over-specialisation - Society of Legal Scholars Centenary Lecture 28th November.
Speeches by serving judges are, of course, extra-judicial matters and are not necessarily indicative as to how the particular judge would decide any actual case. However, speeches reveal not only information about the law and legal practice but also reveal something of the personality and attitudes to law of the speaker. Things have moved on considerably from the days of Lord Chancellor Kilmuir - (post of 2nd December 2011). At the present time, there seems to be an excess of speech-making and it may (emphasis on "may") be that certain judges are risking an appearance of aligning themselves with some members of the present government who undoubtedly wish to limit the influence within the UK of bodies such as the European Court of Human Rights. Such an "impression" would be singularly unfortunate. I leave it to the reader to look at the speeches and form a judgment on this point.
Links:
27th November 2013 - The Guardian - Joshua Rozenberg - Laying down the Laws: human rights court shouldn't have the last word.
2nd December 2013 - Francis FitzGibbon QC - Conspicuous Sumption
3rd December - Spare us from radical judges
3rd December - Thinking Legally - Hoffmann, Laws and Sumption: they come to bury the ECHR, not to praise it
- Lord Neuberger ~ Recent Speeches
Supreme Court of VictoriaOur own Supreme Court is now in vacation until the next legal year commences in October. Lord Neuberger, the court's President, is busy in Australia and New Zealand delivering speeches. In a speech at the Supreme...
- Human Rights Day ~ 65 Years Since The Universal Declaration Of Human Rights
10th December - Human Rights Day. In a letter to The Telegraph, leaders of many 'civil society groups' have urged that Britain stands firm on the European Convention on Human Rights and the Human Rights Act. Both of these were inspired...
- My Thoughts (as A Citizen) On Lord Sumption's Azlan Shah Lecture
On 20th November, Lord Sumption (Justice of the Supreme Court) delivered the 27th Sultan Azlan Shah Lecture in Kuala Lumpur - The Limits of Law. This was followed by Lord Justice Laws on 27th November in the Hamlyn Lectures 2013 - see Lecture 3...
- Lady Hale Joins In ~ Speech At Warwick 28th November ~ And The Attorney-general's View On 'europe'
Following hard on the heels of Lord Sumption and Lord Justice Laws, Lady Hale (Deputy President of the Supreme Court) has joined the fray on human rights. Here is a link to her speech at Warwick on 28th November. Here is an antidote...
- Legal Miscellany
Supreme Court UK ~ 16/10/13The Royal Charter on the Press: Head of Legal Blog has published an item examining in some detail the drafting of the Royal Charter on Self Regulation of the Press. See also High Tomlinson QC at Inforrm's blog - Leveson,...
Law and Rights
Weekend reading ~ a "conference" of speeches
Whether or not there is a collective noun for "speeches" - (perhaps a "conference" of speeches?) - there have been many in recent days.
Lord Judge - former Lord Chief Justice - Bar Council Annual Law Reform Lecture 21st November - The evidence of child victims: the next stage
Speeches by Supreme Court Justices:
- Lord Carnwath gives the Garner Lecture 2013 (PDF)
The Common laws of the environment ? at home and abroad
19 November 2013 - Lord Carnwath gives the ALBA Annual Lecture (PDF)
From judicial outrage to sliding scales ? where next for Wednesbury?
12 November 2013 - Lord Neuberger at the ARBRIX Annual Conference, London (PDF)
Address to property arbitrators
12 November 2013 - Lord Clarke gives the Bracton Lecture at the University of Exeter Law School (PDF)
What shall we do about fraudluent claims?
8 November 2013 - Lord Sumption at the Denning Society (PDF)
The Disunited Kingdom: England, Ireland and Scotland
5 November 2013
Lord Sumption - 27th Sultan Azlan Shah Lecture, Kuala Lumpur - The Limits of Law
Lord Justice Laws - Hamlyn Lectures 2013 - Lecture 3 Common Law and Europe The first two Hamlyn lectures are entitled - 1. Common Law and State Powre - 2. Common Law and Extremism.
In an article, Lord Neuberger (President of the Supreme Court) expressed views about short term prison sentences sentencing - Daily Mail 26th November - "One of the country?s most senior judges provoked fury last night when he criticised short jail sentences for interfering with the home lives of criminals. Lord Neuberger, president of the Supreme Court, said he rejected the idea that a couple of months behind bars ? and what he called ?the clang of the prison gates? ? could help bring criminals to their senses. Instead, he warned such sentences ?can be disruptive? for the prisoner?s job and home life. The judge made his comments after visiting Holloway women?s prison in North London."
Speeches by serving judges are, of course, extra-judicial matters and are not necessarily indicative as to how the particular judge would decide any actual case. However, speeches reveal not only information about the law and legal practice but also reveal something of the personality and attitudes to law of the speaker. Things have moved on considerably from the days of Lord Chancellor Kilmuir - (post of 2nd December 2011). At the present time, there seems to be an excess of speech-making and it may (emphasis on "may") be that certain judges are risking an appearance of aligning themselves with some members of the present government who undoubtedly wish to limit the influence within the UK of bodies such as the European Court of Human Rights. Such an "impression" would be singularly unfortunate. I leave it to the reader to look at the speeches and form a judgment on this point.
Links:
27th November 2013 - The Guardian - Joshua Rozenberg - Laying down the Laws: human rights court shouldn't have the last word.
2nd December 2013 - Francis FitzGibbon QC - Conspicuous Sumption
3rd December - Spare us from radical judges
3rd December - Thinking Legally - Hoffmann, Laws and Sumption: they come to bury the ECHR, not to praise it
- Lord Neuberger ~ Recent Speeches
Supreme Court of VictoriaOur own Supreme Court is now in vacation until the next legal year commences in October. Lord Neuberger, the court's President, is busy in Australia and New Zealand delivering speeches. In a speech at the Supreme...
- Human Rights Day ~ 65 Years Since The Universal Declaration Of Human Rights
10th December - Human Rights Day. In a letter to The Telegraph, leaders of many 'civil society groups' have urged that Britain stands firm on the European Convention on Human Rights and the Human Rights Act. Both of these were inspired...
- My Thoughts (as A Citizen) On Lord Sumption's Azlan Shah Lecture
On 20th November, Lord Sumption (Justice of the Supreme Court) delivered the 27th Sultan Azlan Shah Lecture in Kuala Lumpur - The Limits of Law. This was followed by Lord Justice Laws on 27th November in the Hamlyn Lectures 2013 - see Lecture 3...
- Lady Hale Joins In ~ Speech At Warwick 28th November ~ And The Attorney-general's View On 'europe'
Following hard on the heels of Lord Sumption and Lord Justice Laws, Lady Hale (Deputy President of the Supreme Court) has joined the fray on human rights. Here is a link to her speech at Warwick on 28th November. Here is an antidote...
- Legal Miscellany
Supreme Court UK ~ 16/10/13The Royal Charter on the Press: Head of Legal Blog has published an item examining in some detail the drafting of the Royal Charter on Self Regulation of the Press. See also High Tomlinson QC at Inforrm's blog - Leveson,...