Law and Rights
On 28th October, the government's Public Bodies Bill received its first reading in Parliament - actually it has been first introduced via the House of Lords. We all knew that, mainly for economic reasons, a "Bonfire of the Quangos" was being planned but the interesting question was just what form the legislation would take.
We now know that the plan is to hand Ministers sweeping powers to abolish, merge, or modify these public bodies or offices. The powers are to be exercised by "Orders" (in the form of Statutory Instruments). Although those orders have to be laid in draft form before Parliament and an "affirmative resolution" of each House obtained, the reality is that, in practice, only rarely will there be any debate.
The basic ministerial powers to abolish etc. are set out in Clauses 1 to 6 which have to be read with Schedules 1 to 6. In exercising their powers to make orders, Ministers have to "consider" the matters set out in Clause 8.
The Bill is replete with "Henry VIII" powers. For example, under Clause 11, a Minister is permitted to make certain amendments to Schedules 1 to 6. Under Clause 27, an order may repeal, revoke or amend an enactment whenever passed or made. The Bill contains some restrictions on the use of these powers. Under Clause 20, an order may not authorise the creation of a power to make subordinate legislation; or grant a power of forcible entry/search or seizure; or grant a power to compel the giving of evidence. Under Clause 22 - an order may not create or authorise the creation of criminal offences punishable with imprisonment for more than 2 years. Surely, that is far too extensive a right granted to Ministers to create new criminal offences. One might be forgiven for thinking that earlier this year the coalition government had mentioned introducing a mechanism to prevent the proliferation of unnecessary new criminal offences - see here.
This Bill will extend to England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. [There are various clauses in the Bill dealing more specifically with Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland].
Once this Bill is on the statute book as an Act, it will be there as a permanent extension to Ministerial powers exercisable with quite minimal Parliamentary oversight.
On 4th November 2010 the Solicitors Journal published - "Lords rap government over hasty bonfire of quangos." In July 2010. the Lord Chief Justice expressed considerable concern over the use of "Henry VIII" powers - see Speech by Lord Judge at the Mansion House dinner for H.M. Judges. It appears that, since Ministers like such clauses, their use will continue unabated. Please also see UK Human Rights Blog 5th November 2010.
Addendum 9th November: See The Guardian 9th November (Public Bodies Bill - a vampire law) which has picked up on the rather objectionable nature of this Bill.
For a further post please see UK Human Rights Blog - "Henry VIII stalks the Public Bodies Bill."
Addendum 11th November: See Joshua Rozenberg in the Law Society Gazette - 11th November. Rozenberg argues that this Bill, if it were to become law, would destroy the independence from the executive which many public bodies are supposed to have.
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill
The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill was introduced to the House of Commons on 9th May 2013. The Bill is sponsored by the Home Office and the text of the Bill, as at the date of this post, is HERE. There are 153 clauses and 8 schedules. ...
- At Westminster, Henry Viii Is Alive And Kicking !
Today it is reported that the 'Eurozone' continues to be in recession - (The Guardian 15th May). Yesterday, a DRAFT European Union (Referendum) Bill was published on behalf of the Conservative Party - BBC 14th May. The Bill provides...
- Overview Of Bills Before Parliament And The Crime And Justice Bill Part 1 (national Crime Agency)
The focus of this post is the government's Crime and Courts Bill which received its 1st Reading in the House of Lords on 10th May. 2nd reading is scheduled for 28th May. However, a few other Bills should be noted including the government's...
- The "legal Aid, Sentencing And Punishment Of Offenders Bill" - A Quick Glance - A Lot To Look At And Much Unhappiness
With additions Introduction: On 21st June, the Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor (Kenneth Clarke QC MP) introduced into Parliament his Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill. Along with the Bill,...
- The Ian Tomlinson Case - A Manslaughter Prosecution: Victims Commissioner: Fixed Term Parliaments And Other Bills
Politicians at G20 in 2009The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has announced that there is to be a prosecution for manslaughter in relation to the death of Mr Ian Tomlinson. P.C. Simon Harwood is to be charged. It is a matter of public record...
Law and Rights
A breathtaking Bill of which even Henry VIII would have been proud ...!
We now know that the plan is to hand Ministers sweeping powers to abolish, merge, or modify these public bodies or offices. The powers are to be exercised by "Orders" (in the form of Statutory Instruments). Although those orders have to be laid in draft form before Parliament and an "affirmative resolution" of each House obtained, the reality is that, in practice, only rarely will there be any debate.
The basic ministerial powers to abolish etc. are set out in Clauses 1 to 6 which have to be read with Schedules 1 to 6. In exercising their powers to make orders, Ministers have to "consider" the matters set out in Clause 8.
The Bill is replete with "Henry VIII" powers. For example, under Clause 11, a Minister is permitted to make certain amendments to Schedules 1 to 6. Under Clause 27, an order may repeal, revoke or amend an enactment whenever passed or made. The Bill contains some restrictions on the use of these powers. Under Clause 20, an order may not authorise the creation of a power to make subordinate legislation; or grant a power of forcible entry/search or seizure; or grant a power to compel the giving of evidence. Under Clause 22 - an order may not create or authorise the creation of criminal offences punishable with imprisonment for more than 2 years. Surely, that is far too extensive a right granted to Ministers to create new criminal offences. One might be forgiven for thinking that earlier this year the coalition government had mentioned introducing a mechanism to prevent the proliferation of unnecessary new criminal offences - see here.
This Bill will extend to England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. [There are various clauses in the Bill dealing more specifically with Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland].
Once this Bill is on the statute book as an Act, it will be there as a permanent extension to Ministerial powers exercisable with quite minimal Parliamentary oversight.
On 4th November 2010 the Solicitors Journal published - "Lords rap government over hasty bonfire of quangos." In July 2010. the Lord Chief Justice expressed considerable concern over the use of "Henry VIII" powers - see Speech by Lord Judge at the Mansion House dinner for H.M. Judges. It appears that, since Ministers like such clauses, their use will continue unabated. Please also see UK Human Rights Blog 5th November 2010.
Addendum 9th November: See The Guardian 9th November (Public Bodies Bill - a vampire law) which has picked up on the rather objectionable nature of this Bill.
For a further post please see UK Human Rights Blog - "Henry VIII stalks the Public Bodies Bill."
Addendum 11th November: See Joshua Rozenberg in the Law Society Gazette - 11th November. Rozenberg argues that this Bill, if it were to become law, would destroy the independence from the executive which many public bodies are supposed to have.
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill
The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill was introduced to the House of Commons on 9th May 2013. The Bill is sponsored by the Home Office and the text of the Bill, as at the date of this post, is HERE. There are 153 clauses and 8 schedules. ...
- At Westminster, Henry Viii Is Alive And Kicking !
Today it is reported that the 'Eurozone' continues to be in recession - (The Guardian 15th May). Yesterday, a DRAFT European Union (Referendum) Bill was published on behalf of the Conservative Party - BBC 14th May. The Bill provides...
- Overview Of Bills Before Parliament And The Crime And Justice Bill Part 1 (national Crime Agency)
The focus of this post is the government's Crime and Courts Bill which received its 1st Reading in the House of Lords on 10th May. 2nd reading is scheduled for 28th May. However, a few other Bills should be noted including the government's...
- The "legal Aid, Sentencing And Punishment Of Offenders Bill" - A Quick Glance - A Lot To Look At And Much Unhappiness
With additions Introduction: On 21st June, the Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor (Kenneth Clarke QC MP) introduced into Parliament his Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill. Along with the Bill,...
- The Ian Tomlinson Case - A Manslaughter Prosecution: Victims Commissioner: Fixed Term Parliaments And Other Bills
Politicians at G20 in 2009The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has announced that there is to be a prosecution for manslaughter in relation to the death of Mr Ian Tomlinson. P.C. Simon Harwood is to be charged. It is a matter of public record...