Law and Rights
The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill was introduced to the House of Commons on 9th May 2013. The Bill is sponsored by the Home Office and the text of the Bill, as at the date of this post, is HERE. There are 153 clauses and 8 schedules. The Bill will affect a large number of areas of the law and will grant considerable additional powers to the police and to other bodies such as local authorities.
It is also worth noting that, whilst the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) is in force, there is at least the long-stop of human rights to act as a brake on some of these extensive powers since public authorities are required to act compatibly with convention rights (section 6). We would enter a very uncertain and worrying time if the HRA were to be repealed and judicial review of official decisions and actions was curtailed (as government is now seeking to do). Perhaps that is precisely why some Ministers (including the present Home Secretary) seek withdrawal from the European Convention and repeal of the HRA.
Part 1 - Injunctions to prevent nuisance and annoyance - a wide power here for the court to grant an injunction applicable to any person aged 10 or over who engages in or threatens to engage in conduct capable of causing nuisance or annoyance to any person. There are certain conditions which must apply. Note: a Youth Court will have power to make such orders.
Part 2 - Criminal behaviour orders - these may be made upon a prosecution application but the person must have been convicted of an offence first.
Part 3 - Dispersal powers - a police power to direct persons to leave an area and not return for an exclusion period
Part 4 - Community Protection Notices; Public Spaces Protection Orders; Closure of Premises
Part 5 - Recovery of possession of dwelling houses on anti-social behaviour grounds
Part 6 - Local Involvement and accountability
Part 7 - Dangerous dogs
Part 8 - Firearms
Part 9 - Forced Marriage
Part 10 - Policing: College of Policing; Review bodies for police remuneration; the IPCC; Chief Officers of Police; Local policing bodies; Miscellaneous items (these are important!)
Part 11 - Extradition
Part 12 - Criminal Justice and Court fees - clarifies the law on compensation for miscarriage of justice (Cl 143); trial by jury for low value shoplifting (Cl 144); amends the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005 in relation to persons at risk; amends the law on surcharges; court and tribunal fees.
Part 13 - General including a power for Ministers to make 'minor and consequential' amendments to the Act itself. (Such powers only create additional complexity to the law and add costs to legal work).
There is much in every part of this Bill requiring detailed examination and I shall return to this. One striking feature of modern legislative activity is that the law grows ever more complex as more and more layers of power over the citizen are granted to the police and others (e.g. local authorities). As each layer is granted the seeds are sown for further layers to be needed in the future. Powers granted never seem to be quite enough for the authorities and they come back and ask for more!
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill ~ Possible Amendment
UPDATE 9th January: The amendment set out below was carried in the House of Lords by a majority of 178. The debate may be viewed via Democracy Live. An amendment has been moved to the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill. ...
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill ~ Ipnas
Update 8th January: An amendment to Clause 1 of the Bill has been put forward in the House of Lords. See HERE. This amendment was carried - see also Democracy Live. The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill has...
- Forced Marriage ~ Enforcement Of Protection Orders
May a Police Force apply for a person to be committed to prison for contempt of court for breach of a Forced Marriage Protection Order (FMPO) when the police were not the applicants who obtained the order? The answer is NO according to Holman J...
- Elected Police Commissioners. Is This A Good Move?
The previous post on this blog took an early overview of the Police Reform and Social Responsibility Bill presented to Parliament on 1st December. Existing Police Authorities will be abolished and there will be elected Police and Crime Commissioners. ...
- A Breathtaking Bill Of Which Even Henry Viii Would Have Been Proud ...!
On 28th October, the government's Public Bodies Bill received its first reading in Parliament - actually it has been first introduced via the House of Lords. We all knew that, mainly for economic reasons, a "Bonfire of the Quangos" was being...
Law and Rights
The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill
It is also worth noting that, whilst the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) is in force, there is at least the long-stop of human rights to act as a brake on some of these extensive powers since public authorities are required to act compatibly with convention rights (section 6). We would enter a very uncertain and worrying time if the HRA were to be repealed and judicial review of official decisions and actions was curtailed (as government is now seeking to do). Perhaps that is precisely why some Ministers (including the present Home Secretary) seek withdrawal from the European Convention and repeal of the HRA.
Part 1 - Injunctions to prevent nuisance and annoyance - a wide power here for the court to grant an injunction applicable to any person aged 10 or over who engages in or threatens to engage in conduct capable of causing nuisance or annoyance to any person. There are certain conditions which must apply. Note: a Youth Court will have power to make such orders.
Part 2 - Criminal behaviour orders - these may be made upon a prosecution application but the person must have been convicted of an offence first.
Part 3 - Dispersal powers - a police power to direct persons to leave an area and not return for an exclusion period
Part 4 - Community Protection Notices; Public Spaces Protection Orders; Closure of Premises
Part 5 - Recovery of possession of dwelling houses on anti-social behaviour grounds
Part 6 - Local Involvement and accountability
Part 7 - Dangerous dogs
Part 8 - Firearms
Part 9 - Forced Marriage
Part 10 - Policing: College of Policing; Review bodies for police remuneration; the IPCC; Chief Officers of Police; Local policing bodies; Miscellaneous items (these are important!)
Part 11 - Extradition
Part 12 - Criminal Justice and Court fees - clarifies the law on compensation for miscarriage of justice (Cl 143); trial by jury for low value shoplifting (Cl 144); amends the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005 in relation to persons at risk; amends the law on surcharges; court and tribunal fees.
Part 13 - General including a power for Ministers to make 'minor and consequential' amendments to the Act itself. (Such powers only create additional complexity to the law and add costs to legal work).
There is much in every part of this Bill requiring detailed examination and I shall return to this. One striking feature of modern legislative activity is that the law grows ever more complex as more and more layers of power over the citizen are granted to the police and others (e.g. local authorities). As each layer is granted the seeds are sown for further layers to be needed in the future. Powers granted never seem to be quite enough for the authorities and they come back and ask for more!
Oliver Twist asks Bumble for more. Bumble had the power to grant or refuse.
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill ~ Possible Amendment
UPDATE 9th January: The amendment set out below was carried in the House of Lords by a majority of 178. The debate may be viewed via Democracy Live. An amendment has been moved to the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill. ...
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime And Policing Bill ~ Ipnas
Update 8th January: An amendment to Clause 1 of the Bill has been put forward in the House of Lords. See HERE. This amendment was carried - see also Democracy Live. The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill has...
- Forced Marriage ~ Enforcement Of Protection Orders
May a Police Force apply for a person to be committed to prison for contempt of court for breach of a Forced Marriage Protection Order (FMPO) when the police were not the applicants who obtained the order? The answer is NO according to Holman J...
- Elected Police Commissioners. Is This A Good Move?
The previous post on this blog took an early overview of the Police Reform and Social Responsibility Bill presented to Parliament on 1st December. Existing Police Authorities will be abolished and there will be elected Police and Crime Commissioners. ...
- A Breathtaking Bill Of Which Even Henry Viii Would Have Been Proud ...!
On 28th October, the government's Public Bodies Bill received its first reading in Parliament - actually it has been first introduced via the House of Lords. We all knew that, mainly for economic reasons, a "Bonfire of the Quangos" was being...